• Home
  • Books
  • Clinging to Old Classics can Go Hand in Hand with Banning Books

Clinging to Old Classics can Go Hand in Hand with Banning Books

Too often, we forget that fights about what we shouldn’t read are also battles over what we should read.  And that every time someone attempts to ban Toni Morrison or Ta-Nehisi Coates, they’re also trying to corral our kids back to Hawthorne and Hemingway, Dante, and Dickens. So perhaps it isn’t surprising that during a flood of book bans, we’re also seeing a fresh effort to rally forces in the defense of the so-called classics. Hence, an article in the National Review claims that great books need a “massive salvage operation.”

Required readings in education are filled exclusively with the dead, white, godly men of Europe, stunned at the extent to which these authors still both fill and structure the national conversation. Last October, the New York Times reported breaking news from the field of Chaucer studies. And the October issue of the New Yorker claims that the 400-year-old John Donne is “more contemporary than ever.” And these are all from just the past month. And we don’t just see the media’s preference for the canon in the content they cover. We see it in the way that Canon structures its coverage.

This hit me most forcefully when I read an otherwise provocative article on literature produced by artificial intelligence. It ends with a series of pieces written by the AI at the request of the author in the style of a variety of well-known writers. Almost every one of them comes straight from an introductory English class taught in 1970: Homer, William Shakespeare, Philip Larkin, Sylvia Plath, Robert Frost, Emily Dickinson, and George Orwell.

In continuing to privilege the old classics, journalists make it easier to dismiss other voices as less important, and more discardable, all of which plays right into the hands of the book-banning movement. And even without book banning, the standbys we’ve been reading forever still take up too much of the available room. There is so much other literature out there to learn from; why do we stay within the lines of these old white authors? There is so much more to be learned and experienced than just reading the “classics.” 


Join Our Mailing List

    Recent Articles

    James Patterson Makes Good On $1M Promise To Indies

    Less than 10 months after the day James Patterson swore a million-dollar promise, he has kept his word. The best-selling novelist announced he has donated about $437,000 to 81 independent bookstores — a gift that completes his plan to donate $1 million of his own money to support independent booksellers.

    K-Pop Stars BTS Will Release a Book Telling Their Own Story in July

    BTS , the notorious K pop boy band , has become a global cultural phenomenon, selling out stadiums and dominating charts around the world, and they just recently revealed that they would be releasing their first book Beyond The Story: 10 Year Record of BTS on July 9 , 2023.

    How Annotating Changed My Reading and Writing

    The great thing about annotating is you might understand the text once you read it, but then it slips your mind as the day goes on. I’m going to ramble on for a few paragraphs about why you should be annotating what you read and how to not just read but understand your assignments on a different level.

    Do We Still Need Libraries?

    With people having more access to the internet in their homes, there is less of a need for libraries from the public. This confronts libraries with the threat of closing. This leads to the question of: do we still need libraries? The short and simple answer is yes, and here is why.

    Hey! Are you enjoying NYCTastemakers? Make sure to join our mailing list for NYCTM and never miss the chance to read all of our articles!