• Home
  • Food
  • Do Americans Overestimate How Health Their Food Choices Are?

Do Americans Overestimate How Health Their Food Choices Are?

A new study aiming to find the disconnect between how healthy Americans think they eat and how healthy they actually do, determined that many Americans do not have an accurate perception of their diets. Jessica Thomson, a research epidemiologist at the U.S. Department of Agriculture in Stoneville, Mississippi, and author of the study said, “it appears difficult for adults in the United States to accurately assess the quality of their diets.”

Research asked 9,700 individuals to rate their diet as excellent, very good, good, fair, or poor. Then these people completed 24-hour food questionnaires and the researchers compared the two sets of answers to evaluate how well they matched up. Around 85% of the people were off when they rated the quality of their diet, almost all overestimating how healthy it was. 

Many perceived their diet as good, however, researchers found that it was often actually poor. Those who rated their diet as poor we often much more accurate, more than 9 times out of 10 matching their rating to the researcher’s rating. In the other categories between 1% and 18% of the participants assessed the quality of their diets accurately. 

More research is needed to understand how to bridge the gap between people’s perceptions of the health of their diets and the reality of it. Thomas says that the first step is to consider what factors people use when thinking about how healthily they are eating. A large commonality among the people studied in this case and others are that they need to eat more fruits, vegetables, healthy whole grains, and fewer fats and fried foods. 

According to Shelley Maniscalco, a dietitian based in Washington D.C. reviewed the findings and believes the key is to make nutritious foods taste good. Providing people with recipes that are easy to follow takes away the pressure of making huge dietary changes all at once. The disconnect could be bridged if people understood why certain foods are or are not healthy and made it easier for them to shift away from the unhealthy. 


Join Our Mailing List

    Recent Articles

    Food historian, Cruz Miguel Ortiz Cuadra, Dies at Age 67

    Renowned food historian, author, and educator, Cruz Miguel Ortiz Cuadra has died at the age of 67.  His brother noted that, although the author had been in remission from a battle with lung cancer, he had recently suffered a heart attack that led to a downturn in his health.

    After Four Years, Ben and Jerry’s Brings Back Free Cone Day

    The pandemic cost us our mobility and our gatherings. It shed light on the small things, the people, and the places that we take for granted. On April 3rd, we get one of those small things back. After a four-year hiatus, out of an abundance of caution for the safety of their fans and loyal customers, Ben and Jerry’s is bringing back free cone day.

    The Top 12 Bed And Breakfasts Around The World

    Imagine finding out you have a really rich aunt who lives in a beautiful historic home in France. Well, that’s what staying at the Château de Beauvais would feel like exactly. With antiques covering the Chateau, beautiful windows, and long decorated hallways. The Chateau comes with more than enough accommodations. Just to list a few, A lush garden accompanied by a pool and shared lounge and bar,. All units come with a tv, electric teapot, shower, bath wifi, and of course an amazing vibe. Who could be mad staying at the Château de Beauvais in France, not me?

    Hidden Valley Ranch Launches New Ice Cream Flavor

    Ranch is an all-time favorite; whether for salad or for dipping pizza, most Americans have a love for Hidden Valley’s ranch dressing. What many people did not see coming was ranch-flavored ice cream!

    Is Vegetarianism Really Healthy?

    I have been a devout vegetarian for a year and a half now, and I can confidently say that as long as my diet is my choice, I will never go back to eating meat. There are far too many benefits to not eating meat that far outweighs any perceived negative consequences. For starters, it’s the more ethical choice (when compared to the majority’s omnivorous diet). On behalf of both animals that needn’t be ranched for the sake of being slaughtered and eaten and for the environment, which- as a whole- could stand to bear a few more vegetarian converts in order to reduce the number of greenhouse gasses occupying our current atmosphere. Not to mention the wide variety of flavors and cuisines that going vegetarian opens up for people. As it turns out, in eliminating one food source, I consequently gained a whole cookbook’s worth of bold flavors and creative dishes. Since becoming vegetarian, I have felt more like the person I want to be, and I am grateful for the choice I make every day.

    Food Delivery Apps Post-Pandemic: A New Norm

    Before the world experienced complete isolation and the height of social distancing, food either had to be consumed outside (restaurants, fast foods, etc.) or prepared after getting the ingredients from outside (supermarkets, farmers’ markets, etc.). Food delivery apps were a last resort; they were not the main goal.

    Hey! Are you enjoying NYCTastemakers? Make sure to join our mailing list for NYCTM and never miss the chance to read all of our articles!