• Home
  • Theater
  • Film: Does it Make or Break Theatrical Productions?

Film: Does it Make or Break Theatrical Productions?

Throughout the years, filmmakers have begun adapting theatrical performances more and more, but how much is too much, and where are the discrepancies? Film adaptations of theatrical productions frequently do them an injustice. Post-Production tools change the way the story is told, and the relationship between the storyteller and audience member is fundamentally different. 

I think the biggest issue with film adaptations of theater productions boils down to one detrimental factor, and it is that the two are different mediums of storytelling. One immerses you in the world of the characters and their story, while the other serves as more of a window into the said world. Because the two are different art mediums, there are bound to be discrepancies in how they are translated into one another. 

One of the most distinguishing differences between film and theater productions is that film has a post-production phase and access to a whole array of specialized tools to create a more realistic world. Tools like editing, animation, CGI, etc., enable filmmakers to bring monsters to life, create detailed fantasy landscapes, show us smaller details up close, and so much more. One goal of the film is to transcend reality, creating a world for the viewer’s mind to escape to. The film has the ability to make you believe that the stories exist in their own coherent world. But the drawback as a viewer is that- you are just that- a viewer. When you are in the theater watching a story unfold, you become a part of it. The actors’ emotions are more tangible, the power of singers’ voices physically resonates throughout the space, and you become physically immersed in the world. You can feel the energy of the story in the real world. As an audience member in live production, your energy affects the actors and their own energy, which in turn, results in a more organic delivery of lines and overall production. The story becomes not only real but authentic, having experienced it as it happened.

Furthermore, the access to post-production tools that filmmakers have can impact the way a story is told, not just in terms of immersion, as I already mentioned, but in terms of what is actually seen. When actors are on a stage performing, the audience can see a variety of characters at any given time, seeing how a scene unfolds on a larger scale. But in film, this dynamic between audience and scene becomes less clear cut, as the director is able to draw the audience’s attention to whatever they deem important. It is a useful storytelling technique, but in adaptations of productions with large musical numbers, it can limit how we understand things like choreography or how the characters are related in space.

While the film has many creative advantages, ultimately, not every show will translate from stage to screen very well. Creators should acknowledge the medium’s differences and strive to create content that best utilizes each given medium’s advantages to telling a more compelling story.


Join Our Mailing List

    Recent Articles

    Why Warm-Ups Matter

    For many people, the life of an actor is one that appears glamorous and exciting, but there is often a fear that inhibits people from pursuing this lifestyle. This fear is, unfortunately, one that cannot be avoided by an actor as simply as a claustrophobe might avoid small spaces. Performance anxiety is a very real and very limiting fear that often confronts people and deters them from following their passion for performing. Though it can be incredibly fun and cathartic to perform, it can also be very hard at times for actors to overcome the anxiety that comes with bearing one’s emotions and actions to an audience. Thankfully though, there is a way to work through this roadblock. By spending enough time warming up before a performance, actors may soothe their anxiety enough for them to put on a show. The physicality and social aspects of acting warm-ups make warm-ups a well-suited weapon for combating performance anxiety and thus putting on a better show.

    Why Schools Need More Drama Education

    One of the most memorable learning experiences in my days as a grade schooler didn’t take place inside a classroom, but rather on the stage of my quaint elementary school’s small auditorium. A traveling acting duo–a man and woman, whose names I’ve sadly forgotten– stopped by our school to sweep us up in a two-day improv training experience, where the children of my grade got to romp about on stage and build upon a variety of kid-imagined scenarios in the name of theater. I found the whole thing amazing, and it connected me and my classmates in a way that I had never experienced before. Though I had no formal knowledge of the technical benefits of drama instruction, I knew even then that this was something everyone should experience.

    How Helping Backstage Can Get You On Stage

    If you have ever wanted to be in the spotlight but have found yourself deterred from taking on the challenge of an audition, then I have the perfect solution for you. While the glitz and glamor of acting on stage is what catches most people’s eye in the theater, it isn’t always possible to get on stage, whether that be because you couldn’t land the part, or didn’t have the confidence to take on an audition. Thankfully though, there is a way to engage with the theater that doesn’t involve performing for an audience. Every theater production needs a crew to put together the world that the cast will be acting in. Take it from me, someone who has been in both the cast and crew before, working in a theater crew is a great way to build up the confidence and know-how needed to nail that next audition.

    4 Musicals Set for Movie Adaptations

    It isn’t uncommon for beloved classics to be revived, rewritten, and retold over time, and musicals are no exception. There have been several musical-to-film adaptations over the years, and that stream isn’t ending anytime soon. Sure, some film retellings have flopped, but there are also a large number of iconic stage-to-screen revivals that honor the original medium of a story in an entirely new, beautifully cinematic way. Here are four upcoming musicals set for movie adaptations that will hopefully join the ranks of those legendary revivals.

    Three Reasons to go See a Play This Holiday Season

    Looking for a new tradition to shake up the holiday season? Well I have the perfect suggestion. Going out to see a play or show is the perfect way to celebrate the holiday season. Not only does it allow people an opportunity to spend time with their loved ones and those within their communities, but it represents the spirit of philanthropy, giving back, and uniting communities.
    Going out to see a play is a great way to support your community. Most community theaters try to put on some sort of production for the holidays, and taking the time to go and see what they have been working on is a great way to acknowledge all of the time and effort that the cast and crew put into the show during months of rehearsals.

    KPOP Ends Run On Broadway Early

    The production of KPOP will end its run on Broadway early after receiving poor reviews and grossing less in ticket sales than initially expected. The production was previewed at the Circle in the Square Theatre on October 13th and opened on November 27th. So far, the show has had 44 previews and just 17 reviews. KPOP’s last performance will be at the same Circle in the Square Theatre this Sunday.

    Hey! Are you enjoying NYCTastemakers? Make sure to join our mailing list for NYCTM and never miss the chance to read all of our articles!