• Home
  • TV
  • The Era of the Cop Show is Over

The Era of the Cop Show is Over

From Law and Order to Brooklyn Nine-Nine, police procedurals and cop comedies have been a staple in the entertainment industry since the successful debut of the 1981 police drama Cagney & Lacey. These shows have a lengthy history of eulogizing law enforcement, often presenting an unchallenged view of their work in a way that doesn’t reflect the reality of the criminal justice system. But after the rise of the Black Lives Matter movement as a response to the ongoing problem of police brutality against African Americans, increased public scrutiny surrounding police has called into question the necessity of cop shows–which are now popularly referred to as “copaganda”. But I think the answer to everyone’s question regarding their relevance has already been answered by the American people at large: cop shows have officially run their course. 

In June 2020, a poll ran by Morning Consult, and The Hollywood Reporter found that 56% of all respondents and 59% of Black respondents said that cop shows “should change to better represent the criminal justice system.” Such calls for change have caused TV networks to retool their programming, attempting to address systemic issues in policing in their shows. Some shows, such as Live PD, were even canceled.

However, I find the media’s attempts to soften the police’s image disingenuous at best; if you were to look at a few cops shows airing right now, you’ll find that little has actually changed for the better. While references are made to racism, police brutality, and “serving the community,” these show’s formats and premises have ultimately remained the same–and still, they’re influencing Americans into adopting the belief that law enforcement, and the dangerous tactics they use, are wholly good and necessary in upholding morality. 

“These entertainment media depictions of police use of force have helped to cultivate a sense of reality that does not really exist when it comes to police use of force, often resulting in a belief that certain uses of force cases are rare,” says Dr. Franklin T Wilson, a Criminology and Criminal Justice professor at Indiana State University. “We know through cultivation theory research that unless a person has a personal experience with an issue, the more one consumes specific messaging, be it imagery or statements of information, the more they are likely to adopt it as fact […] If you couple all of this with the fact that law enforcement related programs have accounted for 20-30% of programming since the 1970s, it’s hard to imagine it has not had an impact.”

With all this in mind, it’s no wonder why many have now moved on from police-themed media. And as police departments around the country resist defunding efforts and double down on the attitudes that have made them more of an enemy than a protector in the eyes of millions, I think it’s irresponsible for the media to continue championing them until a substantial change is made.

Share:

Join Our Mailing List

    Recent Articles

    Warner Bros. Television Studios Close to Striking Animation Deal with Amazon For DC-Branded Content

    Warner Brothers According to Channing Dungey, Television Studios is close to finalizing a significant animation agreement with Amazon for DC-branded content. The studio is “exploring animated IP on different platforms,” including WBD-owned HBO Max, Dungey hinted at the news at Content London.“With animation we used to be about staying in-house but now we are doing it on different platforms,” she added. “HBO Max is the first stop but we are in the process of closing a big deal with Amazon featuring DC branded content in animation.”

    How Netflix’s Downfall Will Affect You

    Since Netflix went public in 2002, the streaming giant has changed the way people all over the world access Movies and TV. Netflix has over 221 million subscribers in over 190 different countries. It gets over 10% of global internet traffic, has received 226 different awards and at one point peaked at a market cap of 314 billion dollars. Despite holding a monopoly over streaming services throughout the 2000s and 2010s, Netflix has begun to lose its control over the industry.

    New Show The Santa Clauses is the Perfect Christmas Throwback

    Disney has just released its latest addition to The Santa Clause, the Christmas trilogy that started back in 1994. But this isn’t another movie. This time Disney is shaking things up with a tv series, called The Santa Clauses. The show, which premiered on Disney Plus two days ago, picks up years after the last film took place, with Tim Allen’s character, Scott Calvin (a.k.a. Santa) trying to go into retirement. The show will follow him as he tries to select the next Santa to succeed him so that he may retire and leave the North Pole with his family.

    The Irony of Reality TV Shows

    Reality tv. It’s one of society’s most common guilty pleasures and yet it is still shrouded in veils upon veils of negative stigma. Perhaps this is because it is the one genre of tv that invites viewers to judge real people, as opposed to characters that are written and performed. Or perhaps, it is because the lives that are often documented through the lens of “reality tv” are often wildly out of touch with those being led by viewers. I mean – it goes without saying that most people don’t find themselves in situations where they must give out single roses to their suitors. With that being said though, I think there lies a certain understanding between producers and viewers that the content within reality shows is so rarely derived wholly and naturally from reality itself, and that- by nature- reality tv is a sort of oxymoron. It is nothing but irony, as it claims to be completely real in that it captures the unscripted reactions of real people, but then proceeds to put these- singular- people into scenarios that are far from realistic.

    The Mandalorian: Release Date and More

    The Star Wars franchise struck gold a few years ago when they released the hit show The Mandalorian back in 2019. The show follows a lone ranger and Mandalorian, Din Djarin, on a journey through time and space to protect the alien child, Grogu (“Baby Yoda” for those who never learned his name), from enemy forces. As the show has gone on, the bond between the two characters has grown, and at the end of its second season, we all watched in tears as the father-son dynamic between the two became solidified in its heartwarming season 2 finale (a quick note for those who aren’t caught up with the show yet, the rest of this article will contain spoilers, so read at your own risk).

    When Will We Be Rid of the “Spicy Latina” Trope?

    To say that I was hungry for Latina representation as a preteen would certainly be an understatement; simply put, I was ravenous. As per the customs of Internet fandom, especially in the days of my youth, I would headcanon (that is, assert a non-canon identity onto) characters who I could easily imagine as Latina or Latino while eating up what little actual representation I could find.

    Hey! Are you enjoying NYCTastemakers? Make sure to join our mailing list for NYCTM and never miss the chance to read all of our articles!