• Home
  • Politics
  • What the US means by ‘catastrophic consequences’ in response to Putin’s nuclear threat

What the US means by ‘catastrophic consequences’ in response to Putin’s nuclear threat

The West’s possible responses range from military, including nuclear strikes, to economic sanctions against Russia.

Bob Seely, a British MP and expert in Russian nuclear strategy, says the West’s reaction would need to be finely judged as “there is a difference of perception which is important to understand.”

First, while tactical nuclear weapons use is serious in Russia, it may not be met with the same condemnation as it is in the West.

Second, tactical nuclear weapons were seen as a deterrent to Western dominance in very high-tech precision non-nuclear weapons in recent Russian nuclear doctrine; thus, they were part of a usable arsenal.

Third, tactical nuclear weapons could be viewed as weapons to de-escalate a crisis – the so-called escalate to de-escalate theory – in which a nuclear weapon is activated as a warning.

According to William Albergue, Director of Strategy, Technology, and Arms Control at the International Institute for Strategic Studies, if they are used, a proportionate military response would be to target an airbase or intelligence hub in Crimea.

Similarly, “a couple of strikes in Russia” plus a larger number in Russian-held areas of Ukraine, he told the Daily Telegraph, would be appropriate.

Of course, the US would not want to “go it alone” and would instead seek military assistance from countries such as the United Kingdom and France, as seen in the 2011 strikes against Libya.

Radars or intelligence and surveillance systems linked to any nuclear strike would most likely be the target of a Western response. Russian early-warning or command and control nodes, such as headquarters, would be equally vulnerable.

These targets would most likely be in Russia rather than Belarus or Russian-controlled areas of Ukraine.

“They would shy away from attacking Russian satellites,” Mr. Alberque says, as the targeting “space-based assets” has been discussed among the permanent five members of the UN Security Council and deemed “off limits”.

Major General (retired) Rupert Jones believes the West could respond in a variety of ways if Putin orders the use of nuclear weapons in Ukraine.

A precision strike against a Russian navy ship, for example, or a targeted campaign against Moscow’s Air Force would be conventional responses, albeit a direct attack by NATO.

Whatever action was taken, the goal must have been to “create uncertainty” about future responses.


Join Our Mailing List

    Recent Articles

    Why The Sunshine Protection Act Makes the Most Sense

    Imagine a world where everyone wakes up feeling refreshed every morning. They get up and tackle their daily responsibilities with a renewed sense of energy and enthusiasm, and at the end of the day, they have time to pursue their passions. They go to sleep feeling accomplished and relaxed. This world may sound like a distant fantasy to some, but the Sunshine Protection Act could make it a reality. The Sunshine Protection Act is an act that was passed by the Senate earlier in March of this year, with the goal of making Daylight Saving Time a permanent thing in the U.S.. That would mean springing forward one last time in order to regain the extra hour of daylight we “lose” when we fall back, and then afterwards, never worrying about time changes again. The Sunshine Protection Act would be beneficial for all people as the repercussions of these time changes have detrimental implications on people’s physical and mental well being, that tragically often results in death.

    Virginia Rep. Donald McEachin Dies at 61

    US Representative Aston Donald McEachin, a Democrat from Virginia, died on Monday just weeks after winning reelection to Congress, his office said in a statement late Monday night. He was 61 years old.

    Why is the Quality of our Politicians So Poor?

    The United States’ political arena used to have a veil of professionalism that no longer exists in a Post-Trump era. Nothing better represents the aesthetics of politics changing than Fox news criticizing Obama for wearing an unpresidential tan suit, and then a year later, vocally supporting a candidate who brought up his political opponents small hand size in debates. Trump’s election as president then encouraged record numbers of unqualified candidates to run in this year’s midterm elections, from ex pro athletes to TV show hosts.

    Former Kentucky Governor and KFC Magnate John Y. Brown Jr Dies at 88

    John Y. Brown Jr., the magnate who helped build KFC into a global fast food sensation and used his momentum to serve one term as Kentucky governor, has died at the age of 88. According to Brown’s family, the businessman and multimillionaire succumbed to complications from COVID-19 at a hospital in Lexington, KY. He is set to lie in the state capitol from 10 am to 7 pm. Tuesday (Nov. 29), with his family hosting a public visitation in the rotunda from 3 pm. to 7 pm. The public is invited to attend.

    Sarah Palin Loses House for Alaska

    Democrat candidate, Mary Peltola, beat Sarah Palin in the race for Alaska’s seat in the House. The win for Petola made her the first Native Alaskan to earn a seat in the U.S. Congress. The victory for Petola is also interesting because she won the seat for the Democratic party in a state that has been considered Republican-dominated for the last several decades.

    What Caused the Saturday Night Colorado Shooting?

    Saturday night, the day before Sunday’s Transgender Day of Remembrance, a gunman killed five and injured 17 people at the gay nightclub Club Q in Colorado Springs, Colorado. The gunman has since been indicted and charged with five counts of murder and five counts of bias-motivated crimes.

    Hey! Are you enjoying NYCTastemakers? Make sure to join our mailing list for NYCTM and never miss the chance to read all of our articles!