• Home
  • Books
  • Why the Book Always Seems Better Than the Film Adaptation

Why the Book Always Seems Better Than the Film Adaptation

It’s a common occurrence, I think, to tell someone about a movie you just saw that you personally believe to be very good. You tell them that you thought the acting was great, the story was emotionally resonant, and that you just had an overall great time watching it. Suddenly, your friend, who has been very eager to speak since hearing the film’s title, chimes in saying “if you think that was good, the book is ten times better!” The question is why they believed the book was better than the film, despite them liking the film, too.

This is a very normal thing when a book is adapted into a film. From the announcement of the project, fans of the source material are filled with excitement and place expectations on the film based on what they experienced while reading. I’m pretty sure we’ve all done this; I did it multiple times before, but every time this happens, it also leads to fans saying the book was better.

This, specifically, happens when the movies are pleasant and faithful to the book, and it’s even worse when the movie is bad or just completely doesn’t do the original any justice. A novel is a longer and more investing experience, you normally go through a book in a couple of days or even months. There is so much nuance and complexity that a story loses when it is adapted into a film, that you would feel as if the book were superior. The other aspect is that, when reading, you paint your own picture in your head of how these characters look and act.

It’s only natural that fans would say the book is better, so maybe next time you hear about a film adaptation for a popular book, you should look into reading it first.


Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest
Share on email

Join Our Mailing List

    Recent Articles

    YOU Author, Caroline Kepnes, To Continue Book Series

    “A book is far greater than most hands it passes through. Some simply aren’t worthy.” Joe Goldberg said, deadpan. The talented author behind the book series that is depicted on Netflix’s popular original series,YOU, has announced she will be continuing the book series for a third installment titled ‘You Loved Me’ and teased at an official fourth one.

    Best Book to Movie Adaptations

    Over the past few years, we have seen some successful movies adapted from YA (Young Adult) novels or less popular books. We’ve also seen some terrible adaptations such as the Percy Jackson movies, The Cat in the Hat, The Giver, the Divergent series… etc. Today we are going to look at some of the best book to movie adaptations.

    Hey! Are you enjoying NYCTastemakers? Make sure to join our mailing list for NYCTM and never miss the chance to read all of our articles!