Fans and critics alike have been analyzing Olivia Rodrigo’s “Guts,” her highly awaited second album, in detail since its release. With the tour behind Rodrigo, it’s fair to wonder what fans were hoping for from her most recent effort, which left them longing for the feel of her debut album, “Sour.”
“Sour” raised the standard for Rodrigo’s future work with its electronic-infused tunes and heartfelt ballads. Her latest album, “Guts” is influenced by 2000s rock in contrast, and sounds like the rock soundtracks included in coming-of-age movies from the 90s and early 2000s. For some, the change brought back fond memories of that period, but for others, it meant losing the distinctive sound that was “Sour.”
A major reason why people didn’t like it was that Rodrigo’s visual choices were quite like her first album. The lack of originality in the visual design disappointed some in a field where musicians often reinvent themselves with new albums. The recurrent usage of purple across the albums served to bolster the idea of immobility, rather than progress.
There is some disagreement among critics as to whether Rodrigo’s most recent work demonstrates true creative development, or a dearth of innovation. The track “drivers license” and other songs from “Sour” displayed Rodrigo’s musical talent and powerful lyrics, whereas “get him back!” and other songs from “Guts” provide a new musical environment while delving into topics of love and loss.
Amidst all the arguments, however, there is a respect for the unique qualities of each record. The music videos for “Sour” were famously eye-catching and groundbreaking, while those for “Guts” were criticized for lacking originality and charm.
When delving into Rodrigo’s story, it’s important to remember the bigger picture of the music business. Many people are quick to criticize and overly analyze successful female musicians such as Taylor Swift and Rodrigo because society is slow to recognize young women as strong individuals.
Without the cloud of Swift comparisons hanging over her, Rodrigo is clearly forging her own path as she begins her tour. “Guts” exemplifies her maturation as an artist by revealing a break from convention while being faithful to her story. As we delve into Rodrigo’s most recent album, we can hear her message loud and clear in the first single—a proclamation of who she is, and her determination to create her musical legacy in the way she sees fit.